▶ Your Answer : There are ample supports for the author’s claim that the reasons why Moai statues were built are for several social, religious, and cultural facts. However, the professor in this lecture gives some rebuttals.
First, the professor argues that annual celebrating for winners is easy to discount because the island’s history is been only five centuries. To be specific, even if the moai rewards were built by the winning chiefs annually, in fact, the number of statues is accounted for 9 hundred not 5 hundred. This encounters the reading passage’s claim that the figures were constructed for meaningful leaders on the island as a kind of trophy for the entire clan.
Next, the professor maintains that each of the statues has different viewpoints and they are far from universal directs. Some are seeing forwards and others are looking down the ground. Moreover, on the island, religious piece of stuff or sculptures for ritual and ceremony were not found. This fact contradicts the reading passage’s argument that these giant figures served as intermediary presence relation between the human being in the earth and gods above the sky.
Finally, the professor contends that the theory that these are made by reverence for their ancestors is far-fetching. The moai statues are facing opposite directions, usually North or East. Some masonry works are directed to the West. Furthermore, their DNA resulted in the evidence that they are the relative of Polynesian, Polynesians were largely settled at North sites or South ones. Thus, it is hard to consider that they came from the West places. This cast doubt on the reading passage’s suggestion that the residents on the island built the moai construction in the honor of their ancestors who have come from Westside.
|